A legal practitioner, Richard Nii Amarh, has underscored the steep legal hurdles convicted persons face when seeking bail pending the outcome of an appeal, stressing that courts do not grant such applications on the back of unverified claims.
Mr Amarh, who serves as the Head of Legal at Legitimacy and Rule of Law, explained that the legal threshold shifts dramatically once a court of competent jurisdiction hands down a conviction and sentence. Unlike pre-trial bail—where an accused person enjoys the constitutional presumption of innocence—an applicant seeking bail after conviction is already deemed guilty in the eyes of the law.
Speaking during an interview on Nyankonton Mu Nsem on Rainbow Radio 87.5FM, he noted that judicial discretion in such matters is exercised with extreme caution, making post-conviction bail a rare exception rather than a standard entitlement.
His remarks follow the Accra High Court’s decision to dismiss an application for bail pending appeal filed by the convicted former Ashanti Regional Chairman of the New Patriotic Party (NPP), Bernard Antwi-Boasiako, widely known as Chairman Wontumi.
“Once a conviction has been secured, the presumption of innocence no longer applies, so the court approaches bail with a very different mindset. You are no longer dealing with a suspect; you are dealing with someone whose guilt has been established,” Mr Amarh stated.
Addressing questions on why recent claims of an alleged plot to poison the former NPP regional chairman in custody failed to sway the court, the lawyer pointed out that correctional facilities are manned by state security personnel, and judges rely strictly on hard evidence rather than conjecture.
“The prisons are guarded by trained security officers, so a court of law cannot act on mere allegations that lack concrete proof. Until an official investigation is carried out and prison authorities substantiate those claims, they remain unverified assertions and cannot form the basis for granting bail,” he explained.
Mr Amarh added that the burden now rests squarely on Chairman Wontumi’s legal team to adduce credible evidence to back their claims, noting that without such proof, it is difficult to see how a fresh bid on those grounds would succeed.
Outlining the strict legal criteria required for bail pending appeal, he indicated that an applicant must demonstrate exceptional or extraordinary circumstances showing that continued incarceration would result in a substantial miscarriage of justice. According to him, this could involve life-threatening health conditions that cannot be managed in custody, or a glaring error of law or fact apparent on the face of the trial record that gives the appeal an overwhelming likelihood of success.
“An applicant cannot simply come to court because they disagree with the trial judge’s verdict. There must be substantial legal grounds showing that the appeal has high prospects of succeeding, or that keeping the person in prison would be manifestly unjust,” he said.
He further observed that even when an applicant meets these stringent thresholds, the court still weighs broader public interest considerations to ensure that releasing the convict will not undermine the administration of justice. Where bail is eventually granted, judges typically attach strict conditions—including substantial sureties, the surrender of travel documents, and regular reporting to security agencies—to guarantee the appellant remains within the jurisdiction until the appeal is determined.
By: Rainbowradioonline.com/Ghana















