Tuesday, February 7, 2023
Rainbow Radio
  • Home
  • General News
  • Governance
  • Sports
  • Politics
  • Health
  • Entertainment
  • Economy
  • Home
  • General News
  • Governance
  • Sports
  • Politics
  • Health
  • Entertainment
  • Economy
No Result
View All Result
Rainbow Radio Online
Home General News

The court cannot direct how Parl should work-Kwaku Azar

March 9, 2022

Center for Democratic Development (CDD) Ghana Fellow on Law and Justice Prof Kwaku Asare has opined that the Supreme Court of Ghana cannot tell Parliament how to run its affairs.

Reacting to the ruling of the court that deputy speakers can vote and be counted to form a quorum, the lawyer noted that Parliament and the Courts are coequal branches of government and neither can tell the other how to run its affairs.

RelatedPosts

Speaker welcomes new Minority leadership, commends outgoing leaders

Haruna Iddrisu was never a sellout as perceived by some NDC members – Majority Leader

Free SHS has become a conduit for large-scale corruption and theft – MP

In his view, “Overruling the standing order that requires the Speaker Pro Tempore to act as an unbiased umpire with no vote makes a mockery of Tuffuor and could very well be a Pyrrhic victory of style over substance.”

Read his full reaction below:

Consider Order 225, which provides that “The Chairman [of a Committee] shall not have an original vote, but in the event of an equality of votes he shall give a casting vote.”

Can the Supreme Court declare the order unconstitutional because it deprives the Chairman, therefore his constituents, of an original vote?

I think not! Nor can the Court, in my opinion, invalidate the casting vote because it makes the Chairman a sole appellate judge of the committee’s decisions.

In this regard, I agree with Justice Sowah, in the oft cited but hardly understood Tuffuor case, when he says “that the law and custom of Parliament is a distinct body of law and, as constitutional experts, do
put it, “unknown to the courts.” And therefore the courts take judicial notice of what has happened in Parliament. The courts do not, and cannot, inquire into how Parliament went about its business.”

Parliament and the Courts are coequal branches of government and neither can tell the other how to run its affairs.

If Parliament, in its wisdom and consistent with the rules applicable to the Speaker, decides that a Speaker pro tempore should not take part in debates, vote, or should not caucus with his party on a matter pending while he presides, it is not for any Court to inquire into it just as it is not for Parliament to inquire into how Justices are chosen to sit on cases at the SC or why some cases are disposed of with expediency and others seem to disappear into oblivion.

Nor am I impressed by the argument that because a Speaker Pro Tempore represents a constituency, it is impermissible for him to be denied a vote while presiding.

The Constitution itself makes provision for denying MPs the vote under certain circumstances. For instance, Article 104(5) provides that “A member who is a party to or a partner in a firm which is a party to a contract with the Government shall declare his interest and shall not vote on any question relating to the contract.”

Just as Article 104(5) denies an MP the vote because of the clear conflict of interest, Parliament can reasonably demand that a Speaker Pro Tempore not be allowed to vote, debate or act as a biased umpire.

To reason otherwise, is to invite the MPs to treat a Speaker Pro Tempore as an ordinary MP, not entitled to the respect and courtesies that are due to the office of the Speaker.

Overruling the standing order that requires the Speaker Pro Tempore to act as an unbiased umpire with no vote makes a mockery of Tuffuor and could very well be a Pyrrhic victory of style over substance.

SALL is the cardinal sin of the 8th Parliament.

Da Yie!

ShareTweetShareShare

Related Posts

bAGBIN

Speaker welcomes new Minority leadership, commends outgoing leaders

February 7, 2023
Kyei-Mensah-Haruna-Iddrisu

Haruna Iddrisu was never a sellout as perceived by some NDC members – Majority Leader

February 7, 2023
FREE SHS

Free SHS has become a conduit for large-scale corruption and theft – MP

February 7, 2023
FIRE-SERVICE (1)

We’II soon implement the installation of fire alarm systems in homes to reduce outbreaks – GNFS

February 7, 2023
jk9

KT Hammond nominated new Trades Minister, Bryan Acheampong heads to Agric Ministry

February 7, 2023
san

Roar over sand winning at Domponiase

February 7, 2023

Recent News

bAGBIN

Speaker welcomes new Minority leadership, commends outgoing leaders

February 7, 2023
Kyei-Mensah-Haruna-Iddrisu

Haruna Iddrisu was never a sellout as perceived by some NDC members – Majority Leader

February 7, 2023
FREE SHS

Free SHS has become a conduit for large-scale corruption and theft – MP

February 7, 2023
FIRE-SERVICE (1)

We’II soon implement the installation of fire alarm systems in homes to reduce outbreaks – GNFS

February 7, 2023
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
qz

The appreciation of the cedi against the dollar will be short-lived so don’t over jubilate – Haruna to gov’t

December 17, 2022
z455

Bui Power Authority calls for partnership to do more on climate change program at COP27

November 22, 2022

Rainbow Radio expands its platform presence on 92.4Fm in UK

September 5, 2022
zz

Family of Asuma Banda calls on Prez, Mahama, Chief Imam to intervene so their brother is sent to Kintampo

December 7, 2022

Hello world!

bAGBIN

Speaker welcomes new Minority leadership, commends outgoing leaders

travel4

Washington prepares for Donald Trump’s big moment

travel1

CS:GO ELeague Major pools and tournament schedule announced

bAGBIN

Speaker welcomes new Minority leadership, commends outgoing leaders

February 7, 2023
Kyei-Mensah-Haruna-Iddrisu

Haruna Iddrisu was never a sellout as perceived by some NDC members – Majority Leader

February 7, 2023
FREE SHS

Free SHS has become a conduit for large-scale corruption and theft – MP

February 7, 2023
FIRE-SERVICE (1)

We’II soon implement the installation of fire alarm systems in homes to reduce outbreaks – GNFS

February 7, 2023

Stay Connected test

  • 121 Followers
  • 20.2k Followers
  • 185k Subscribers
  • 23.7k Followers
  • 99 Subscribers
Rainbow Radio Online

© 2022 Rainbow Radio International

Navigate Site

  • General News
  • World
  • Sports
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Politics
  • Health
  • Opinion
  • Economy
  • Odd News
  • Culture
  • Lifestyle
  • Lifestyle
  • Governance
  • Technology

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result

© 2022 Rainbow Radio International

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
Go to mobile version